the shareholder commons blog

click on a post to read more

Join the System-Level Conversation

Join the System-Level Conversation

Provide Input at Upcoming Knowledge Lab Roundtables Join us for our next virtual System-Level Investing Knowledge Lab Roundtables to move from listening to action following the conclusion of our Knowledge Lab Listening Tour. We’ll dig into three foundational areas of...

read more
Spotlight on Portfolios on the Ballot 2026

Spotlight on Portfolios on the Ballot 2026

Looking Back on Four Years of Portfolios on the Ballot Before Portfolios on the Ballot launched in 2023, TSC aimed to show investors who use a company-specific focus that portfolio-wide risk is embedded throughout the economy and that those risks are actionable in...

read more
Update from The Shareholder Commons: Leadership Transition

Update from The Shareholder Commons: Leadership Transition

Dear Colleagues, I will be stepping down as CEO of The Shareholder Commons, effective June 30, 2026. I am sure the timing will be a surprise to many of our allies, as it does feel as if the ideas we have been promoting are gaining traction at an increasing rate--why...

read more
When Policy Fails

When Policy Fails

When Policy Fails, Investors Must Step Up For years, there has been a debate among those working to fight climate change: does time spent on investor stewardship pressing companies to limit their greenhouse gas emissions distract from the essential work of changing...

read more
Building a New Culture

Building a New Culture

Building a New Culture In our last newsletter of 2025, we noted that system stewardship was maturing and that body of relevant work was expanding accordingly. One of the most encouraging signs of this maturation is that new publications about system stewardship are...

read more
A Year of Systems-First Progress

A Year of Systems-First Progress

As the year-end approaches, we are reflecting with gratitude on a period marked by extraordinary progress in system stewardship. Throughout the year, investors, researchers, and others have stepped forward to acknowledge that safeguarding long-term portfolio returns...

read more
Portfolios Over Companies: When to Say No to Alpha

Portfolios Over Companies: When to Say No to Alpha

Recently, TSC’s CEO Rick Alexander had the opportunity to speak at the Intentional Endowments Network's 2025 Annual Forum. His remarks are reprinted here: Good morning. Thanks for that nice introduction and to everyone at IEN for putting this forum together. Instead...

read more
Branching Out: System Stewardship’s Expanded Reach

Branching Out: System Stewardship’s Expanded Reach

Our May newsletter – System Stewardship in Bloom – highlighted how investors and others are embracing portfolio-wide responsibility: recognizing that undiversifiable risks threaten entire portfolios, and that long-term returns depend on the health of the economic,...

read more
Portfolios on the Ballot Returns to Close Out the Year

Portfolios on the Ballot Returns to Close Out the Year

As shareholder activity heats up across the Southern Hemisphere, Portfolios on the Ballot (POTB) has re-launched with a fresh website and a new series of POTB digest emails to spotlight systems-first proposals going to a vote through the end of 2025. From boardrooms...

read more
Turning a Corner in System Stewardship

Turning a Corner in System Stewardship

August marked our sixth anniversary at The Shareholder Commons, and we have been taking a hard look at where we have been, and where we want to go over the next phase of our organization’s work. In 2020, the notion that diversified investors need to focus on the...

read more
System Stewardship Isn’t Politics. It’s Capitalism

System Stewardship Isn’t Politics. It’s Capitalism

Readers of this newsletter know we believe investors should encourage companies to eschew practices that damage critical systems. This is just common sense: most investors are diversified, so that the value of their portfolios rises and falls with the health of the...

read more
Shareholder Voting Must Account for Systemic Risk

Shareholder Voting Must Account for Systemic Risk

Shareholder Voting Must Account for Systemic Risk The most recent ECGI Blog featured a post from TSC CEO Rick Alexander arguing that investor decisions must evolve to account for systemic risks like climate change, inequality, and the erosion of democratic norms....

read more
Public Markets Belong to Investors, Not Executives

Public Markets Belong to Investors, Not Executives

In its latest report, the Business Roundtable (“BRT”)—the CEOs of the largest companies in the United States—makes a sweeping claim: that the proxy system is broken, harming investors by discouraging companies from going public. But a closer look reveals a more...

read more
The AMR-Biodiversity-Climate Nexus

The AMR-Biodiversity-Climate Nexus

Investors who wish to support our AMR guardrail but who have not yet formally identified the topic as a current stewardship priority have asked us to help them understand how AMR is related to biodiversity loss and climate change. To support these investors, we have...

read more
TSC’s Proxy Voting Guide Now Live

TSC’s Proxy Voting Guide Now Live

The Shareholder Commons has launched its latest proxy voting guide, Portfolios on the Ballot 2025, which flags proxy campaigns that include a diversified investor perspective, promoting guardrails that can protect the social and environmental foundations supporting...

read more
Silencing Shareholders

Silencing Shareholders

An anti-shareholder movement—often mislabeled as “anti-ESG”—is silencing everyday investors’ voices in the United States, including the 50% of private sector workers who participate in 401(k) retirement plans. Government Capture Anti-shareholder activists use...

read more
How Guardrails Protect Portfolios

How Guardrails Protect Portfolios

Happy new year! As we embark on another solar orbit, the world around us may feel tumultuous. With the largest economy poised to enter a deregulatory period, investors’ duty to their clients and beneficiaries has not changed. In our September newsletter, we described...

read more
System Stewardship in the News

System Stewardship in the News

Oxfam and Rights CoLab released The Investor Case for Fighting Inequality: How Inequality Harms Investors and What Investors Should Do About It. Focused on the sources and outcomes of socioeconomic inequality, this paper serves to alert investors to the growing body...

read more
Politics Happens | Stewardship in a Deregulatory Environment

Politics Happens | Stewardship in a Deregulatory Environment

Last week, we learned the United States will be governed by a Republican administration for at least four years (and a Republican legislature for at least two years). While there has been some curious political re-alignment going on in the world’s largest economy, it...

read more
Stewardship Tools for Diversified Investors

Stewardship Tools for Diversified Investors

Investors’ portfolios are at risk from a warming planet, a challenged social fabric, and many other threats. COVID-19 and the 2008 financial crisis gave us a glimpse of the interdependent nature of our global economy, while the science around matters such as climate...

read more
ISS & Glass Lewis Need Your Help!

ISS & Glass Lewis Need Your Help!

Modern finance has provided investors with an understanding of risk and return that essentially mandates ownership of stock in hundreds or even thousands of companies, allowing them to earn the high returns of risky equity while limiting the risks that come with...

read more
The False Promise of Government Oversight: Help Is Not Coming

The False Promise of Government Oversight: Help Is Not Coming

“The tsunami of lawsuits against agencies that the [new U.S. Supreme Court decisions] have authorized has the potential to devastate the functioning of the Federal Government.” ~Justice Jackson, dissenting in Corner Post, Inc. v. Board of Governors, FRS   Many...

read more
ExxonMobil Incites System Stewardship

ExxonMobil Incites System Stewardship

Exxon Sues its Shareholders Earlier this year, ExxonMobil (XOM) sued two shareholders that had filed a climate-related proposal for the 2024 annual shareholders’ meeting. Instead of following the straightforward SEC process companies typically use to omit a proposal...

read more
Shareholder Primacy and the Meta Decision

Shareholder Primacy and the Meta Decision

Readers of this space know The Shareholder Commons was involved in a lawsuit against Meta Platforms (the owner of Facebook, Instagram, and other internet services). At the end of April, that litigation came to an end when the Delaware Chancery Court dismissed the...

read more
2024 Guardrails: AGM Season

2024 Guardrails: AGM Season

Our guardrails are in full swing, and investors are increasingly seeing them as tools to protect their portfolios. Investor-mediated guardrails define company operational parameters that safeguard diversified portfolio value, discouraging corporate behavior that...

read more
Proxy Season 2024 | Update on Guardrails

Proxy Season 2024 | Update on Guardrails

As regular readers may know, we’re supporting investors in running two “guardrails” this year: one on antimicrobial resistance (AMR) and one on poverty wages and income inequality, the latter in partnership with our colleagues at ShareAction. We predicate all our work...

read more
Portfolios on the Ballot 2024

Portfolios on the Ballot 2024

Our 2024 proxy voting guide is the first publication specifically designed to help investors vote their proxies on a systems-first basis. HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE REPORT We have collected nearly 60 shareholder initiatives that integrate arguments in the proposal or...

read more
TSC Announces Living Wage Guardrail

TSC Announces Living Wage Guardrail

Poverty wages don’t just undermine workers: inequality perpetuated by low pay at companies such as Walgreens Boots Alliance (NYSE: WBA) threatens the national and global economies with losses that will burden investment portfolios for years to come. Closing the living...

read more
Living Wage and the Engagement Gap

Living Wage and the Engagement Gap

Living Wage & the Engagement Gap Today we publish our new research, “Living Wage and the Engagement Gap,” on the systemic risk of low wages and income inequality to diversified portfolio value, which depends on critical social and environmental systems. Among...

read more
Report from the Field

Report from the Field

Regular readers know our chief complaint about the investing world: too much emphasis on the individual financial performance of portfolio companies, and too little on how those companies affect the systems that underpin investors’ entire portfolios. When push comes...

read more
A System Stewardship Response to ISS’ Policy Survey

A System Stewardship Response to ISS’ Policy Survey

We have provided our responses to the ISS 2023 Policy Survey. Our responses are largely based on the observation that the ISS benchmark voting guidelines are not designed to serve the average institutional investor, who holds a diversified portfolio or is managing...

read more
Launching a Guardrail on Antimicrobial Resistance

Launching a Guardrail on Antimicrobial Resistance

The global economy faces a US$100 trillion headwind over the next three decades from overuse of antimicrobials. TSC is working with institutional investors to implement a Guardrail campaign focused on overuse and abuse of antimicrobials in meat supply chains. The...

read more
The Portfolio Defense of ESG – SSIR

The Portfolio Defense of ESG – SSIR

Shareholders who want portfolio companies to improve their impact on society or the environment are hampered by their reliance on arguments that such changes will improve company value. Such arguments lack credibility when the requested changes are the very same...

read more
Introducing TSC’s Proxy Voting Guide

Introducing TSC’s Proxy Voting Guide

Portfolios on the Ballot   Proxy season allows shareholders to tell companies how they want their capital applied in the real economy. Among other matters, shareholders can press for an end to extractive practices that threaten diversified investors’ financial...

read more
On a Lawsuit at Meta

On a Lawsuit at Meta

Saying the Quiet Part Out Loud On December 16, Meta made a little-noticed filing in response to a shareholder’s lawsuit against the Company and its directors. While the filing has remained largely under the radar, it speaks volumes about the reality of the...

read more
Proxy Season 2023: Teeing Up Guardrails

Proxy Season 2023: Teeing Up Guardrails

We’ve filed shareholder proposals at Hormel Foods (annual meeting date January 31), Tyson Foods (February 9), and McDonald’s (TBD) asking those companies to comply with World Health Organization (“WHO”) Guidelines on Use of Medically Important Antimicrobials in...

read more
You Want Us to Ignore What? A Brief Analysis of anti-ESG Political Rhetoric

You Want Us to Ignore What? A Brief Analysis of anti-ESG Political Rhetoric

Politicians are vilifying “ESG investing”. The trigger for the furor is political opportunism: because ESG issues often mirror political issues, it is easy to mischaracterize them as leftist activism. Texas has already incurred $300-500 million in extra interest obligations by boycotting banks that account for climate impact in their underwriting businesses. This political strategy protects corporations that externalize costs with business plans that don’t account for social and environmental costs. These politicians are enriching corporate executives, but risking the savings of workers.

read more
Climate-related Risks & Diversified Shareholders’ Interests

Climate-related Risks & Diversified Shareholders’ Interests

TSC and B Lab U.S. and Canada submitted a comment letter on the proposed rule. Our letter argues for a disclosure framework that would also support a beta stewardship approach. An alpha-centered investment thesis is simply not viable in the face of the climate threat.

read more
Regulation v. System Stewardship: The Fading Promise of Governmental Intervention

Regulation v. System Stewardship: The Fading Promise of Governmental Intervention

ESG activism has failed to stop companies from externalizing social and environmental costs when they can gain a financial advantage. Critics argue that shareholder activism by corporations and investors oversteps their proper sphere of influence in the U.S. Investor activism must focus on the conflict of interest that exists between individual companies and their diversified shareholders.

read more
Breaking Free from the Business Case Paradigm

Breaking Free from the Business Case Paradigm

Rick Alexander made an appearance on the Breaking the Fever podcast. Rick discusses the need for investors to shift their perspective from one that considers only one company to one that considers the entire portfolio.

read more
The Pernicious Problem of Multi-Class Share Structures

The Pernicious Problem of Multi-Class Share Structures

Bloomberg columnist Matt Levine spelled out the problem with multi-class share structures. It’s time for underwriters such as Goldman Sachs and JPMorgan Chase to stop enabling what the SEC Investor Advocate described as a “festering wound”

read more
Response to System Stewardship Challenges

Response to System Stewardship Challenges

A recent article by Marcel Kahan and Edward B. Rock critiqued the sort of system stewardship we promote at TSC. But the authors do not really question the idea that in some circumstances diversified investment fiduciaries would want to address the threat from portfolio companies that externalize costs to other investees

read more
Johnson & Johnson Proposal Survives SEC Challenge

Johnson & Johnson Proposal Survives SEC Challenge

Johnson & Johnson sought to exclude our proposal asking for a report on the costs it externalizes by limiting access to its COVID-19 vaccine technology, and how its diversified shareholders absorb those costs. By rejecting both arguments, the SEC made clear that shareholders have a legitimate interest in voting on proposals that address the macroeconomic implications of a significant policy issue.

read more
Here Comes Proxy Season

Here Comes Proxy Season

Proxy season 2022 is right around the corner. This edition is dedicated to the 19 shareholder proposals we’re supporting this year. We also highlight a US$46B asset owner CEO’s public support for system stewardship.

read more
Hopeful Signs from a Difficult Year

Hopeful Signs from a Difficult Year

Let’s face it: 2021 brought plenty of disappointments. The pandemic ground on, democratic ideals appeared to be in retreat around the world, and the planet continued to accelerate toward and even past critical boundaries. But if we look upstream, 2021 also provided...

read more

Together, we can fundamentally transform our financial system.  Get involved today.